Our original resources for authors and journals will help you become an expert in academic publishing. LetPub Scientific Journal Selector (2018-2021), Nature Energy published in 2016, UNITED STATES. Additionally, some events lie outside the categories of postulation, consultation, decision and administration as they indicate discussions. Hence, we draw from a growing theoretical literature on digital infrastructures from science and technology studies and also from literature about processes and practices in peer review from the social studies of science. The rejected manuscripts and those to be resubmitted get a special treatment by the editors: the communication about the frustrating decision is thoroughly crafted showing in the network as two vertices about Drafting Decision Letter, notably resulting in longer durations for decisions to be sent to authors. //-->Digital marketing - Wikipedia Recht Manage. To the best of our knowledge, our analysis is one of the very few quantitative analyses of these processes. Consequently, we infer that the infrastructure becomes performative in the sense that an idealized model implemented as software defines what tasks are supported and which are neither supported nor tracked. Benjamin Franklin FRS FRSA FRSE (January 17, 1706 [O.S. While focussing our analysis only on the case of one biomedical publisher, we may infer some more general observations for this realm of research. Different to what the patent for the technology suggests, the actual use of the infrastructure may be particularly complex, revealing the difficulties in managing and maintaining collaboration among different types of actors. Learn more. Editorial management systems are perceived as an infrastructure in this work. For this purpose, we use network analysis: the vertices represent the stages and a (directed) edge is drawn from one stage to another when it is directly following in one items history. Sometimes, it is mentioned, who is involved in the said actions, but sometimes not. Depending on the journal, the assignment may be done by technical staff, the journal's chief editor, or automatic by submission category or author suggestion. In this paper, we present an empirical case study: processual data from a journal management system provide insights into how the peer review process is carried out at four journals of a specific publisher in the biomedical field. For example, the event Preliminary Manuscript Data submitted happens for almost all manuscripts, which is why it does not help us to distinguish manuscript lifecycles in a meaningful way. They can only choose to participate in it or not. According to Star and Bowker, infrastructures are used to enable, maintain and control collaboration among different actors (Star, 1999; Star and Bowker, 2006). In the event of publication, the received date is the date of submission to the journal where the manuscript is published. Nature Such claims are difficult to make given the limitations many studies on editorial peer review face. [CDATA[// >
Who Is The Shortest Person In The World 2021,
Parallel And Perpendicular Lines Answer Key,
Elibap Wellness And Spa Location,
Articles E
